Red meat is 'a scapegoat' for health and climate change

By Michelle Perrett

- Last updated on GMT

Diana Rodgers claims red meat has been unfairly targeted
Diana Rodgers claims red meat has been unfairly targeted

Related tags: Supply chain, Meat & Seafood, Ingredients & nutrition

Red meat production is completely misunderstood and is being unfairly targeted as a scapegoat for concerns about health and climate change, a leading dietician, author and film director has claimed.

Diana Rodgers, a ‘real food’ nutritionist and sustainability advocate, told Hybu Cig Cymru - Meat Promotion Wales’ (HCC) annual conference, that the focus should be on what is the optimal diet for humans and how can it be grown in a sustainable way.

“Red meat is completely misunderstood and being unfairly being targeted as a scapegoat for our concerns about health and our worries about climate change; it’s much easier to pin our worries on something as powerful and polarising as red meat rather than tackling the world’s complex problems and tackling them in a cleverer and more nuanced way,”​ she said.

“There is bundled-up propaganda out there that says that meat causes cancer, heart disease, diabetes; that it’s bad for the environment; it’s unnecessary - why eat meat when we can just engineer proteins in labs? - ​[that] it is unethical; that those who are ‘more enlightened’ have moved beyond meat eating.”

Propaganda

She told HCC’s conference attendees that this propaganda was not only incredibly damaging but wrong. 

She said: “There is no research that has shown a direct cause between red meat and disease; meat is the best source of iron and B12, the most common nutrient deficiencies worldwide. B12 is not available in plant-sourced foods and red meat’s iron is in the wrong form in plants. And, most importantly, the vegan diet is simply a privilege that many don’t have.” 

She highlighted the environmental case for meat claiming that raising cattle on grass in general doesn’t require chemicals, increases soil microbial life and rainfall absorption.

Plant-based meat alternatives

“Look at the price of the plant-based meat alternatives; it’s almost twice as expensive per pound to buy the substitutes. It’s an extractive system where intense chemicals are needed and leave behind a bare, hard, dead soil with increased rainfall runoff and a hotter ground temperature,”​ Rodgers added. 

She also said that artificial meat produced in a lab has absolutely nothing ecologically healthy about it at all. 

“It takes large amounts of chemically grown monocrop, whether it’s wheat corn or soy, to process with a lot of energy to keep the temperatures regulated. It’s just not economically feasible and makes no sense from an energy perspective,​” she added. 

Related news

Show more

Related suppliers

1 comment

Concerns?

Posted by Greg,

Well written Michelle and sound logic Diana! I'll just jump on my soapbox for a quick minute. Our eyes are on the front of our heads and we have canines for a reason in addition to a few other amazing things that make us human, like personal choice. Heck, I had cricket tacos once in Mexico City and they were great! They tasted like corn nuts! I'm all in for continuous improvement when it comes to everything including the environment, health and energy usage efficiency. Why don't we start with probably what is the greatest consumer of our resources, individual comfort. I got a couple of great ideas! How about self contained individual environmental control units and we can manufacture them out of completely recyclable and renewable resources! Darn, I bet somebody already came up with that. Oh well. It's really windy and rainy today and as much as I would love to lounge around in my house coat and drink coffee all day while I wake up. I'm going to go grab my wool sweater, put on some jeans and enjoy a cup of peppermint tea. I do live in Canada after all, it would be kind of sweet if I could just wear shorts and a t-shirt!

Report abuse

Post your comment

We will not publish your email address on the website

These comments have not been moderated. You are encouraged to participate with comments that are relevant to our news stories. You should not post comments that are abusive, threatening, defamatory, misleading or invasive of privacy. For the full terms and conditions for commenting see clause 7 of our Terms and Conditions ‘Participating in Online Communities’. These terms may be updated from time to time, so please read them before posting a comment. Any comment that violates these terms may be removed in its entirety as we do not edit comments. If you wish to complain about a comment please use the "REPORT ABUSE" button or contact the editors.