Milburn NEET review overlooks retention

Big risk problem, danger or challenge, fear of crisis or disaster, courage or determination to overcome problem, vulnerability or hopelessness concept, business people face big wave danger problem.
The food industry reacts to Milburn report. (Getty Images)

The core recommendations of Alan Milburn’s review on young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) have been welcome by the food sector, but many say it fails to address long-term retention.

The Milburn Young People and Work Review was commissioned by the UK Government following a rise in the number of young people not in employment, education, or training.

While NEET figures have barely dipped below 10% in the last 25 years, they’ve reached their highest level in a decade. An estimated 1 million (13.5%) of young people currently fit into this bracket, with 6 in 10 never having had a job.

But the report says that the nation’s chronic state of joblessness is not a result of a ‘snowflake’ generation, with seven in ten wanting to work. Instead, it argues this outcome has been driven by a lack of investment into people.

Former health secretary, Alan Milburn, who led the report, warns if the issue is left unaddressed, it will result in an even higher economic price through lost skills, lower productivity and slower growth.

His ambitious proposals set out several recommendations with the aim of reducing the UK’s NEET rate to around 5% and become one of Europe’s best-performing countries for youth participation by 2036.

Recommendations include a call for more jobs, apprenticeships and work experience; increased accessibility for opportunities, more support and incentives for businesses to employ young people, and a reform of the education system.

Why does the UK have a NEET crisis?

Among the issues highlighted in his report, Milburn points to a fall in youth employment driven by the erosion of entry roles. He also flags concerns over an outdated education sector, which was designed for a predictable economy – and calls for a much-needed modernisation. As part of this, he suggests schools and colleges teach skills for everyday life, including cookery.

For the food sector, which saw the axing of the food A-level some years ago, any move that promotes food -related skills will be a welcome one; as will the news of ample young would-be workers.

It’s no secret that the food manufacturing sector has long suffered a labour shortage. Data shows that in 2025, across the food system there were around 22,000 vacancies advertised at any one time.

The numbers sound like they don’t add up – why, if there are so many jobs and so many young people keen to work, are there so many unemployed young people?

No awareness of food sector

According to Nan Jones, technical policy manager at the British Meat Processors Association (BMPA), the food sector’s skills crisis is partly down to a lack of awareness and understanding of the opportunities available across manufacturing.

For Jones, the recommendations set out in the report are a step in the right direction. However, more action in helping to showcase the sector’s breadth of opportunities is needed.

It is encouraging to see the report taking a longer-term approach, particularly around creating better pathways into work.

Nan Jones, technical policy manager, British Meat Processors Association

“There is a real opportunity to connect young people, including those who are NEET or at risk of becoming NEET, with meaningful employment in an industry that is actively looking to recruit,” Jones comments.

“[But] we would also like to see greater emphasis on engaging with schools and improving careers education, helping young people understand the importance of food production and the breadth of careers available.”

Matthew Reynolds, owner and director of the Education and Training Academy, agrees better access to opportunities can only be a good thing.

“Many young people have little idea what a career on the factory floor can lead to,” he notes.

“A good placement gives them safe, supervised tasks, someone to learn from and a clear next step into an apprenticeship or entry-level role.”

However, he caveats this with: “The practical question is whether smaller manufacturers will get the support they need to give supervisors time to train and mentor young people properly.”

A lack confidence and a need to review recruitment processes

While the sector can spotlight roles, research shows there is also a big confidence issue we need to attend to.

A study from IGD found that 71% of 16-19-year-olds do not believe they have any skills or abilities that would be useful to an employer. Meanwhile, 76% say they need help putting their skills into words before speaking to employers, and 73% say they have skills that are not reflected in their CV.

This insight potentially demonstrates a need to reassess how we recruit in the sector.

The data also indicates an opportunity to shout out about the vast number of roles in food and drink and how young people’s skills and interests can be applied.

While just 18% report that they would consider a career in food and drink, 86% say they would be more likely to once shown the range of roles available and 82% say they would look into the industry if someone showed them how their everyday skills and interests could lead to a job in the sector.

“All young people have things that they are passionate about and that translates into important skills that food and drink employers value highly - the problem is they don’t always realise that or know how to express their skills,” comments Jordan Schwarzenberger, co-founder of Arcade.

“I know from personal experience that working in food and drink is a really exciting thing to do. There are all sorts of entry-level roles available and there’s a real chance to progress into a long-term, rewarding career, and it’s an industry that is open to everyone, in every postcode.”

The review also recommends earlier intervention, calling for primary and secondary schools to flag and support students at risk of becoming NEET.

Gill Pendergrast, sales director at Whitworth Bros, says the focus to reach young people earlier is a welcome tactic: “Through our work with local students and education providers, we’ve seen how valuable it is for young people to meet employers and get a feel for jobs they might never have considered.”

She adds: “One thing we’d like to see as the plans take shape is more opportunity for schools and colleges to work with local businesses to make hands-on work experience easier to access. In food manufacturing, that could give young people a chance to build practical skills and see where careers in areas like engineering, production and food quality could take them. It could also help businesses like ours find and develop the next generation of skilled people.”

Lasting careers

But getting people through the door is only one part of the puzzle.

“The real measure is whether employers can provide them with the skills and support to build lasting careers,” highlights Kate Taylor, apprentice and early careers manager at ABP UK.

“If we’re serious about tackling the rise in NEETs, we need to look beyond getting young people through the door and ensure employers have the resources to help young people stay and thrive, as well as schools and FE institutes better preparing them for the world of work.”

Indeed, while the report calls for more apprenticeships and guaranteed work experience for young people, without support in place for those aged 25+, the plan may stumble at the first hurdle.

“Our concern lies in proposals to reduce government funding for apprentices over the age of 25, which would shift more of the cost onto employers,” flags Bobby Edge-Partington, head of knowledge, learning, and communications at IFST.

“The food industry faces a growing technical skills shortage. We urgently need food scientists and food technologists to help meet the challenges of a rapidly changing world, and many people move into these roles later in their careers. We believe it’s possible to support young people without making it harder for employers to train people over the age of 25 who want to move into a career in food.”

Louise Cairns, the National Skills Academy for Food and Drink’s CEO, agrees the direction of travel is worrying.

“We have concerns about any proposals that could restrict access to apprenticeship funding based primarily on age,” she adds.

“While increasing opportunities for younger people is an important goal, progression and upskilling remain essential throughout a person’s career.

“The food and drink manufacturing sector is undergoing significant technological change, with increasing adoption of automation, digital systems, advanced manufacturing processes and sustainability-focused practices. Employers need access to apprenticeship pathways that support both new entrants and existing employees seeking to progress into higher-skilled roles.”

For Cairns restricting access for older learners will create “unintended consequences” which will limit workforce progression and reduce employer participation at a time when businesses need greater flexibility.

“A successful skills system should increase opportunities for young people while maintaining clear progression routes that support lifelong learning and career development,” she continues.

“The food and drink manufacturing sector offers rewarding careers that are critical to the UK’s economy, food security and growth ambitions. The challenge is not simply preparing people for work; it is ensuring that employers are supported to create the opportunities that allow individuals to succeed.”

National Insurance concerns

The report also sets out proposals to gradually reduce National Insurance (NI) contributions paid by firms.

Increases to employer National Insurance and the National Minimum Wage have been a significant blow to the food and drink sector, making entry-level staff become increasingly expensive - particularly for businesses already operating on tight margins.

The British Frozen Food Federation’s (BFFF) membership research shows the consequences: a third of frozen food businesses claim to have reduced their workforce following the increases last year, while nearly half have introduced recruitment freezes.

“When employing a young person costs almost as much as employing someone with considerably more experience, opportunities for those starting out inevitably suffer,” explains BFFF CEO, Rupert Ashby.

“The Government must now act decisively to ensure that any future increases are balanced against the negative impacts for employability and that they are realistic for businesses. If we are serious about tackling youth unemployment, we must make it affordable for businesses to give young people their first opportunity.”

Chiara Muston, an employment lawyer at Charles Russell Speechlys LLP who works with businesses in the food sector, also raises challenges around NI but brings the argument back to retention.

She points out that while reducing the cost of hiring could help create more entry-level opportunities, employers will still need to demonstrate how younger recruits will be trained, retained and developed if the proposals are to create a genuinely more sustainable workforce.

“Cutting National Insurance could encourage businesses to create entry-level opportunities, but tax incentives cannot be looked at in isolation. If the Government wants employers to take a chance on younger people – particularly across such a reliant sector as food & beverages – with less experience, its employment, tax and skills policies all need to be pulling in the same direction,” she explains.

“For investors in food and drink businesses, the important question is whether these measures can translate into a more sustainable workforce model. Reducing the cost of recruiting younger workers may help businesses fill entry-level roles, but investors will also want management teams to demonstrate how those employees will be trained, retained and developed.”

What’s next?

Not everyone is happy then, but Milburn says his recommendations come with “inevitable trade-offs and dilemmas” due to the scale of the problem the UK is trying to fix.

All the food and drink sector can do now is engage with the Government and various relevant stakeholders and hope it is listened to.

“Employers have a big role to play in the Review’s proposed changes,” adds IFST’s Edge-Partington. “Professional bodies, employers and educators must work together to make the most of this opportunity and bring a new generation into successful careers in the food system.”

UK PM Andy Burnham says he’s keen to act fast on NEET, with the Government promising next steps on welfare reform in the coming weeks, ahead of a white paper next year.

In any case, it’s a major job, requiring huge changes. The Government will be busy leafing through these proposals, which it says will be done in conjunction with the Timms review (on Personal Independence Payment) due certain crossovers.