BMPA CEO: Joined-up food chains need joined-up government

John Powell
John Powell, former Defra head of the agricultural sectors team and now British Meat Processors Association chief executive, is calling for systemic governmental change. (BMPA)

Ongoing volatility is crippling the UK’s food system. But unless policymakers stop viewing the supply chain as a series of unconnected dots, the industry’s biggest challenge will remain unresolved.

Starting on farm our food travels via processors, manufacturers, retailers, food service and export outlets, but ultimately ends being eaten by a consumer. Realistically or practically, one part of the journey outlined cannot be separated from any other.

So why does the government, in many cases, not recognise the need for policymaking to take a more holistic and co-ordinated approach to the supply chain?

As a means of addressing this paradox, I was asked to speak at the Westminster Food & Nutrition Forum policy conference on 6 November. The conference considered various issues around the next steps for food policy in England - implementation, growth, public health, affordability and resilience.

Many of the themes covered by the conference addressed those of relevance to the UK meat industry - and food sector as a whole.

Most notably, this included building food system resilience, touching on points such as:

  • Managing the implications of climatic and geopolitical volatility for domestic production, imports and food security
  • Protecting productive agricultural land
  • Improving access to data and evidence to support resilience planning and evaluation
  • Supporting investment in resilience across farms and supply chains, and reducing reliance on costly inputs

My speech focused on the way policymaking around the supply chain operates, both in terms of structure and priorities. The current approach limits our ability to effectively address the challenges that the food supply chain is facing, such as food system resilience, climate change, food security, obesity, balancing nature protection with food production, and the need for greater investment in farming and food production. This is because they are, at times, effectively competing against each other.

There needs to be a fundamental rethink of how government approaches food policy. that enables them to view the food supply chain in its entirety and not as separate independent entities that by chance just happen to work together to ensure the nation is fed.

What policy dots need to be connected

In this speech at the Westminster Food & Nutrition Forum policy conference, I explored the current set up around strategies, processes and organisations, and argued the case for a major rethink. Here’s a brief overview of points and questions I raised:

1. Strategies

Just within Defra we have the land use framework, the farming road map, the food strategy, Defra’s response to Baroness Batter’s Farming Profitability Review, and the animal welfare strategy. Alongside that we have wider government policies on planning, labour, diet and health, skills and trade to name just a few.

We need to think about how future strategies can sit better together to allow for a more coherent plan around how we produce, process, manufacture and sell/export food.

We also need to consider how can we avoid having policies that conflict or contradict. For example, how to balance food security and climate change adaption (methane emissions).

2. Processes

Data gathering, surveillance, advice, monitoring and enforcement must also be reviewed.

How do we ensure that the plethora of associated activities that are involved in the making of supply chain policy can be more effectively utilised?

We must look at how we share resources and data, how we avoid duplication, and how to operate more transparently.

3. Organisations

Setting aside the individual policies and strategic documents they each produce, how do we get government departments and agencies to work better with industry. How do we also get industry to work better within itself?

This kind of shift will mean Government and industry stakeholders will in turn need to change the way we work, moving the focus from a vertical to a horizontal approach.

A clearer target

During my speech, I also raised how we currently set out key priorities and whether these need to be clearer.

For instance, do we know explicitly what we want to address across the supply chain and what we want the Government to facilitate/fund?

If we’re clearer on the priorities, it should be easier to create supply-chain-wide strategies and implementation programmes.

Five key long-term priorities for the supply chain could be:

  1. Public health
  2. Farming resilience
  3. Affordability
  4. Growth through adaptation
  5. Food security

With the combination of specific and overarching objectives, and the funding of clear activities, we should be able to achieve more of our defined outcomes.

The importance of consumer engagement

This is primarily a conversation that has to be had internally, but it’s a conversation that we also need to take to an external audience if we are to avoid outsourcing the problems we face domestically on climate change, self-sufficiency, food security, and animal welfare.

Education of consumers is perhaps more important than we sometimes realise. Knowing where our food comes from, the value of it, the challenges of production, carcase balance, self-sufficiency, can all address how consumers react to and understand more about the food they consume.

Five key calls to action

  1. Treat the supply chain in totality, not as separate independent components
  2. Link policies, organisations and processes more effectively
  3. Agree our key priorities
  4. Change how we deliver schemes to focus on achieving these priorities
  5. Promote both an inward and outward focused discussion including more consumer education on and involvement in the food system

A familiar foe

We have been facing these challenges for some time and without change will continue to do so.

This shift in direction will primarily have to come from government. This is because they set the policies.

Government will have to establish permanent internal departmental and cross departmental structures that ensure a proper join-up of new policies under design is undertaken both within individual departments, and across all other impacted departments and agencies.

But before any new policies go live, there must be a clear understanding over how they conflict with or complement existing policies. The impacted industry/sector must also been fully engaged in the development of these policy so any implications and/or unexpected consequences have been fully considered and addressed, and to ensure the delivery of policy is consistent.

It is therefore important that we, the industries and sectors impacted by policy, continue to press government for a change in approach and explain why it’s so important to us that new policies are:

  • Developed to be strategic across the supply chain
  • Promote complementarity rather than conflict
  • Are designed together with industry
  • Are delivered proportionately and consistently