Elliott Review

Speed and cash crucial to food fraud strategy

By Rod Addy contact

- Last updated on GMT

The Elliott review was prompted by the discovery of horse in beef products in 2013
The Elliott review was prompted by the discovery of horse in beef products in 2013

Related tags: Professor chris elliott, Food security, Food, Food standards agency

The Elliott Review may count for little in preventing a similar scandal to ‘horsegate’ unless its proposals are implemented swiftly and funded properly, according to experts.

Referring to recommendations to create a coordinated intelligence hub to manage information on international food crime, David Young, partner in law firm Eversheds’ regulatory department, told FoodManufacture.co.uk: “There isn’t any suggestion from him ​[Professor Chris Elliott] that anyone in government has said they will make money available for this.”

Manufacturers’ margins were already squeezed by lacklustre food and drink value sales and the lingering effects of the recession, so the industry was ill-equipped to bear costs itself, he said. “If you are paying for a better system, that’s a good thing, but industry will say, ‘it can’t just be about us’.”

He also questioned whether, with eight months to go before a general election, the report’s recommendations would stay centre stage. “The sceptic in me, looking at these recommendations, is asking whether it will really change anything, whether if we come back in a year’s time consumer confidence will be improved.”

‘Restore confidence’

Anne McIntosh, chairwoman of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs select committee, said the recommendations in the report needed to be implemented swiftly to slam the door on food fraudsters. “I would like to see the government move quickly to restore confidence in the food chain.

“The bottom line is: is the FSA able to respond more quickly to a food scare in the future? I would say yes, with the proviso that we implement the final recommendations in a timely manner.”

Elliott’s review cited a previous government pledge to make £2M available to boost food testing capabilities. McIntosh welcomed this and cautioned: “We need to make sure that money is ring-fenced and not going to be put into other things.”

The EFRA committee plans to quiz all stakeholders about Elliott’s findings in the coming weeks, she said. “One of the things I would like to raise is: the £2M the government has given for testing – is this enough? We have to accept the cost implications across the piece for what he’s proposed.”

‘Sensitivities about additional costs’

In the preface to his Review, Elliott, Professor of food safety and director of the Institute for Global Food Security at Queen’s University Belfast, said: “As with all reviews which impact on industry, particularly small businesses, there are sensitivities about imposing additional costs, and I have been clear that I see no need for additional regulatory burdens.

“I believe that the systems I am proposing will help lift some existing burdens, especially from small businesses.”

McIntosh also said she would be looking to develop a clearer picture of current progress on traceability throughout the supply chain during subsequent EFRA meetings.

The Elliott review into the integrity and assurance of food supply networks ​was finally published yesterday (September 4).​ It was originally expected to be published in July, but was delayed to allow new environment secretary Liz Truss a chance to examine it in greater detail.

Food safety conference

The Food Manufacture Group is holding a one-day conference, Safe and legal food in a changing world​, to equip workers including technical and regulatory personnel with the latest information to help prevent food safety incidents.

To be held at the Heritage Motor Centre at Gaydon, in Warwickshire, on Wednesday October 15, it will be chaired by Colin Dennis, former president of the Institute of Food Science & Technology.

Speakers from Bernard Matthews, the Food Standards Agency, the Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs and the Chartered Institute of Environmental Health are taking part. To book a place, click here or contact Alex Webb at nyrk.jroo@jeoz.pbz​ or call him on: 01293 610431.

Related news

Show more

Related products

Made for Trade – The International Trade Report

Made for Trade – The International Trade Report

Walker Morris | 23-Dec-2021 | Technical / White Paper

In the latest report from Walker Morris, 'Made for Trade – The International Trade Report', we provide insight and investigation into the challenges...

Carbon Reduction for Large Energy Users

Carbon Reduction for Large Energy Users

ESB Energy | 12-Nov-2021 | Product Brochure

ESB Energy Business Solutions can help you meet your companies carbon targets by 2050. We offer a range of sustainable tailored solutions to reduce the...

Related suppliers

1 comment

Horsemeat: Created by "Criminal Gangs" or Opportunity Space

Posted by Duncan,

The concecess, being reported by the press, is that the horsemeat scandal was created by criminal gangs duping industry. True, criminal offences have taken place and likely it is organised crime involved. Alternatively, this "opportunity space" was undoubtedly created by pressures pushed down through the industry with margins squeezed out of reputable manufactuers pockets, resulting in the search for cheapest suppliers who would sign up to contracts / specifications knowingly that they did not comply. The retail model is to blame, as it is from the top that their margins are maintained and the downstream supply chain is pushed to the limit to remove costs. Similar tactics have been used in the dairy industry with milk suppliers barely making a profit. It's not had the same fraudulent outcomes, but without a system or a decent profit potential, it is only a matter of time.

Report abuse

Follow us


View more