Tesco food sold past use-by date deemed a criminal offence

By James Ridler contact

- Last updated on GMT

The ruling of Tesco vs Birmingham Magistrates Court deemed the sale of food past its use-by date a criminal offence
The ruling of Tesco vs Birmingham Magistrates Court deemed the sale of food past its use-by date a criminal offence

Related tags: Regulation

It is a criminal offence to sell food past its use-by date, according to a ruling made in a case against big four retailer Tesco.

The retailer was represented at Birmingham Magistrates Court over charges of selling food past its use-by date in three of its stores visited by environmental health officers on 17 June 2016, 12 April 2016 and 25 May 2017.

An initial judgement by a district judge ruled that Tesco had indeed committed a criminal act under regulation 19 of the Food Safety and Hygiene (England) Regulations 2013​, which makes it an offence to contravene or fail to comply with any specified EU provisions.

In the case against Tesco, presented before Lord Justice Hickinbottom, the judgement hinged on a link between two parts of European food law – the restriction of the sale of unsafe food and the definition of food past its use-by date as unsafe.

Deemed unsafe

Article 24 (1) of the Food Information Regulations ​states that, after the use-by date, food will be deemed as being unsafe, as per article 14(2) to (5) of the regulation.

Schedule 1 to the 2013 Regulation identifies the requirement in article 14(1) as being a ‘requirement that unsafe food must not be placed on the market’.

“The ‘deeming’ provision in the last sentence of article 24(1), provides the critical link between use-by dates and the application of article 14 of the Food Safety Regulation, and is at the heart of this claim,”​ said the judgement.

“On its face, it deems food beyond its labelled use-by date to be ‘unsafe’, so that, by article 14 of the Food Safety Regulation it cannot be ‘placed on the market’.”

Tesco’s response

However, Jonathan Kirk QC, representing Tesco, argued that the use of the term ‘deemed’ in the law was not concrete and therefore greatly open to interpretation. His issue lay in the fact that while the law would deem the product unsafe, in practice the food in question was in fact not unsafe to eat.

Kirk pointed to similar cases where deeming provisions elsewhere in EU regulations were not absolute and were used more as a guideline to which regulations should be followed – such as proper food labelling – and not used for the basis of criminal convictions.

Despite this, Hickinbottom’s view was that the legislation was unambiguous. In his eyes, any food business that was responsible for placing food past its use-by date on store shelves was in breach of article 12 and was thus guilty of an office under regulation 19.

“The conclusion reached by the district judge also favours legal certainty: the words in article 24 of the Food Information Regulations clearly set out the legal consequence if food passed its use-by date is put on the market,”​ said Hickinbottom.

“This enables all FBOs ​[food business operators] to know with a high degree of certainty one (albeit not the only) set of circumstances that will give rise to a breach of article 14 and hence commission of an offence under regulation 19 of the 2003 Regulations.”

Related topics: Chilled foods, Legal

Related news

Show more

comments

Post your comment

We will not publish your email address on the website

These comments have not been moderated. You are encouraged to participate with comments that are relevant to our news stories. You should not post comments that are abusive, threatening, defamatory, misleading or invasive of privacy. For the full terms and conditions for commenting see clause 7 of our Terms and Conditions ‘Participating in Online Communities’. These terms may be updated from time to time, so please read them before posting a comment. Any comment that violates these terms may be removed in its entirety as we do not edit comments. If you wish to complain about a comment please use the "REPORT ABUSE" button or contact the editors.

Follow us

Featured Events

View more

Products

View more

Webinars